Sound Doctrine, Sound Minds, and the Word of Life
When doctrine is unsound—loosely grounded, selectively quoted, or driven by human agendas—it does not simply introduce error. It produces instability. Scripture describes this instability not as ignorance, but as a condition of being divided, tossed, and unsettled. The danger is not thinking too much, but thinking without a stable center.
Murmuring, Confused Reasoning, and the Loss of Orientation
Paul names this danger directly in Philippians:
“Do all things without murmuring (γογγυσμός) and confused reasoning (διαλογισμός)… holding fast to the word of life.” — Philippians 2:14–16
The terms Paul uses are precise. The word murmuring γογγυσμός does not refer to honest questioning or open speech, but to quiet resentment—an inward resistance or confusion that never resolves and never clarifies. It is better to ask questions so to receive wisdom and understanding than to hold something in, this corrodes trust from within.
The word for reasoning διαλογισμός refers not to disciplined reflection but to internally divided reasoning: thought that circles endlessly without coherence, reinforced by other confused voices rather than anchored in wisdom, which implies understanding given.
Paul is not calling believers to stop thinking, this would be dangerous and how men control other men. He is warning against living inside unresolved confusion and judgment. His answer is not silence, submission, or suppression, but orientation—holding fast to the word of life. The question is not whether the mind is active, but what it is fastened to.
James, Divided Judgment, and the Maturation of Faith
James calls this being double-minded and addresses the same condition:
“Let him ask in faith, with no doubting…” (James 1:6)
The word translated “doubting” is διακρίνω (diakrinō' : from "according; from; through" and "judge"). This word does not primarily describe emotional uncertainty or intellectual inquiry. Its core meaning is to judge according to, so one judges either according to belief or unbelief. Going back and forth between both is being double-minded.
Paul describes a principle in Romans 7 that wars against the law of the mind. The Spirit or the mind of Christ, and the carnal mind war against one another. The idea then of being double-minded is judging between competing conclusions. James is not condemning questions; he is describing a mind that goes back and forth never receiving the wisdom it needs to be sound.
“He is a double-minded man (δίψυχος), unstable in all his ways.” (James 1:8)
Double-mindedness is not curiosity. It is a division of the inner life, where competing judgments never resolve. Wisdom, in James, is not instant certainty; it is something received by a mind that refuses to let unbelief become the governing lens through which God’s word is evaluated. He describes the solution, if you lack wisdom ask, and ask in faith, he does not encourage one to be quite.
“Do all things without inward murmuring (γογγυσμός) and confused reasoning (διαλογισμός)… holding fast to the word of life.” — Philippians 2:14–16
The solution is to hold fast to the "word of life." Teaching that encourages knowledge without understanding, that doesn't strengthen faith but fosters unbelief and confusion is not sound. Most unrighteousness we see, but the outwardly obedient and inwardly divisive man who seeks his own, scheming and deceiving, hides in sheep's clothing.
Sound doctrine produces a sound mind, it has saving faith, loves, builds up, edifies, and does not toss children to and fro, which is being double-minded.
Abraham, Unbelief, and the Refusal to Judge by It
Paul’s treatment of Abraham in Romans 4 deepens this picture and corrects many oversimplified accounts of faith.
“No unbelief made him waver (οὐ διεκρίθη τῇ ἀπιστίᾳ) concerning the promise of God, but he was strengthened in faith…” (Romans 4:20)
The grammar matters. The phrase assumes the presence of unbelief (ἀπιστία). Paul does not deny Abraham’s uncertainty; he specifies that Abraham did not judge according to unbelief. Unbelief existed, but it was not allowed to render the final judgement.
This is confirmed by Paul’s next statement:
“... so to be fully convinced (πληροφορηθεὶς) that God was able to do what He had promised.” (Rom. 4:21)
“Fully convinced” describes an end state, not the beginning. Abraham’s faith matured over time. Scripture records misjudgments along the way, including his attempt to resolve the promise through Hagar. These were real failures of discernment, yet Paul frames Abraham’s faith as developmental rather than always firm. Faith was strengthened until convincing took hold.
Scripture therefore allows for tension, struggle, and incomplete understanding—while warning against remaining divided, holding things in, and allowing confusion to reign. Discipleship is a place where individuals can go deeper and develop strong minds.
Jesus modeled preaching, teaching, and discipleship and commissions men to make disciples. He chose twelve out of many and spent years with them (who knows how many hours a day). We also see explicitly how he took a few alone with him at times. Also implicitly we see an individual aspect especially in the Gospel of John.
In The Parable of Sowing Jesus tells us a strong foundation with understanding is key to bearing fruit. Within a biblical Greek context, faith has as it root word the meaning "to be persuaded" and is often described as "divine persuasion". It is not just an intellectual agreement, but what faith exists; firm proof, hope, and assurance. A reliance on God, often acting in response to his revelation.
Faith invites persistence asking and knocking to receive wisdom and life. Unfortunately, many have failed to raise children in this way. "Children should be seen and not heard" is an old proverb meaning children should be quiet and well-behaved in adult company, only speaking when spoken to, reflecting views of obedience and subordination.
I remember one of my very first impressions as a child of going to church was seeing this play out, children who were outwardly obedient in front of adults while a part little demons. I did not know how to put a finger on it but I knew something was wrong, the next Sunday I cried to my mother not to make me go to church.
Jesus spoke against this type of religion that teaches outward obedience without inward change. He said "let the little children come unto me."
Doctrine, Stability, and the Building Up of the Body
Paul’s concern for mental and communal stability comes into focus in Ephesians:
“So that we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes.” (Ephesians 4:14)
Instability here is not caused by questioning, but by doctrine shaped by human cunning—teaching that fragments rather than integrates, that unsettles rather than establishes. Such doctrine produces dependence, confusion, and immaturity. Sound doctrine, by contrast, exists for one purpose:
“For building up the body of Christ.” (Eph. 4:12)
This distinction becomes especially visible in one concrete area.
Money, Ministry, and the Danger of Becoming a Stumbling Block
Few issues reveal the difference between sound doctrine and distorted doctrine more clearly than the handling of money. Paul addresses this not as a peripheral concern, but as central to the integrity of the gospel.
Although Paul affirms that those who labor in the gospel have a right to material support, (which personally I think he is relating to that under the Law, or that priests were entitled to live off the tithing) he repeatedly emphasizes that he chose not to exercise this right:
“We did not use this right, but we endure anything rather than put an obstacle in the way of the gospel of Christ.” (1 Corinthians 9:12)
“I coveted no one’s silver or gold… In all things I have shown you that by working hard in this way we must help the weak.” (Acts 20:33–35)
Paul’s concern was that money or the entitlement to live off people would be an obstacle to the gospel. His concern was doctrinal clarity in lived form. He understood that doctrine shapes perception. If financial dependence distorted motives or undermined trust, it would become a stumbling block, contradicting the gospel it claimed to serve.
This emphasis has often been ignored or justified away, with real consequences. Many today hesitate to enter churches not because of a rejection of Christ or Scripture, but because the gospel has become associated with pressure, obligation, and financial manipulation. That association did not arise from apostolic teaching; it arose from doctrine detached from Paul’s pastoral wisdom.
Vocation in the church, if there is to be one, should be a public servant one, like policemen, firemen, teachers... The love of money is the root of all evil. If there is no limit to how much money ministers make or no limit to their entitlement then it invites wolves, not servants.
Law, Grace, and Doctrinal Regression
The misuse of Scripture reflects another doctrinal regression that Paul confronts directly in Galatians—the return to law as a means of justification and means of living without spiritual guidance, which is equated to walking in the flesh not the Spirit.
“Having begun by the Spirit, are you now being perfected by the flesh?” (Galatians 3:3)
Paul’s concern is not moral laxity but confusion of foundation. When law is reintroduced where grace governs, it does not produce holiness; it produces anxiety, comparison, and fear-driven compliance.
“For freedom Christ has set us free… do not submit again to a yoke of slavery.” (Galatians 5:1)
When law replaces grace as the organizing principle of the community, believers forfeit grace—not as God’s disposition, but as the operative framework of life together.
“You are severed from Christ… you have fallen away from grace.” (Gal. 5:4)
Regression to the Law is one of the most obvious ways to spot unsound doctrine. All scripture is inspired by God for teaching... right? The lack of spiritual discernment and understanding is neglected for Old testament structured teaching without having a spirit of wisdom and revelation in knowing Jesus. The writer of Hebrews tells us these things do not perfect or mature. The goal of ministry Paul writes in Ephesians 4 is to grow children into maturity in Christ, anything else is not sound.
The Root of Bitterness and the Breakdown of Community
This forfeiture of grace explains another serious warning:
“See to it that no one fails to obtain the grace of God; that no root of bitterness springs up and causes trouble, and by it many become defiled.” (Hebrews 12:15)
Bitterness here is not merely emotional resentment. It is systemic. When grace no longer governs, relationships become transactional. Judgment replaces discernment. Comparison replaces love. The result is communal fracture.
This pattern is visible in the church in Corinth. In 1 Corinthians 6, Paul confronts a church marked by judgment, rivalry, and mutual harm:
“Why not rather be wronged? but you yourselves wrong and defraud and this to your brothers!” (1 Cor. 6:7-8)
This is not passivity, but grace-shaped reasoning. A law-governed or self-seeking mind seeks to win; a grace-governed mind seeks to preserve life and unity. When doctrine shifts from grace to law, communities inevitably turn inward, murmuring quietly, bitterness takes root, and begin to devour one another.
Of course Paul is not calling the church to ignore wrong and not live in truth, as he goes on to say "do you not know the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God. Do not be deceived..."
Holding Fast to the Word of Life
We are under grace not as a means to continue in sin to learn to walk as Jesus did. Jesus gives gifts to mature the church, and sound doctrines does just that. Those who truly seek truth and to impart truth do not mind questioning. It is hurtful to the church to live to traditions of unsound doctrines.
Against all of this, Paul’s exhortation in Philippians stands as a governing principle:
“Holding fast to the word of life.”
Believers are not called to hold fast to systems, leaders, traditions, or fear-based structures, but to what gives life. Sound doctrine clarifies rather than fragments, liberates rather than controls, and allows faith to mature rather than demanding instant certainty. The ultimate reality of being a new creation in Christ is "life."
A sound mind is not one without struggle, but one no longer ruled by confusion. It is rooted, founded, established and built up in Christ:
“Rooted and built up in Him and established in the faith.” (Colossians 2:7)
“God has given us… a sound mind (σωφρονισμός).” (2 Timothy 1:7)
This is not blind obedience. Not a call to blindly "trust and obey" but to seek, ask, and knock, give me the bread of life. It is mature faith—anchored in truth, governed by grace, and holding fast to the word of life. When we are sound in mind we are not tossed to and fro, blown about in every wind of doctrine, in human cunningness, craftiness, and deceitfulness, but we hold fast to the word of life
Our ship sails on. Though the winds of stormy doctrines stir waves to toss us to and fro, to hurl us off course and cast us against rocks and unseen dangers, seeking to shipwreck our faith, we hold fast—fixing our eyes on the captain of our salvation, with sound minds anchored and steadied by his words of life, this way!